Do you lose out if you don't receive iDeCo at the same time as your retirement allowance?
“If you don’t receive iDeCo at the same time as your retirement allowance, you lose out.” Have you heard this?
The explanation goes like this. A retirement allowance and an iDeCo lump sum are both taxed as retirement income. Each one’s deduction can be calculated from its own years of service.
However, if the years in which you receive them are close, the deduction is reduced by the overlapping period. So, the story goes, it is better to separate the years of receipt.
Half of this is fact. Half of it goes too far. In this article, we check it against the statutes and worked examples.
Three tax terms, explained first
- Retirement income deduction (taishoku shotoku kōjo) = the amount you can subtract from a retirement allowance and similar payments. It is set by your years of service.
- The previous year or earlier (zennen izen) = the years before that year.
- Lump sum (ichijikin) = a way of receiving the money all at once, rather than as a pension.
Conclusion
- When the years of receipt are close, the overlapping period is not counted in the retirement income deduction. It is a fact that the deduction is reduced.[1][4]
- However, it cannot be said that "you lose out if you don't receive them at the same time." Even if you receive both in the same year, the deduction is simply combined into one.[3]
- If the iDeCo period is entirely contained in the period of service and both payments exceed their deductions, the total deduction and the total taxable retirement income are the same whether you receive them in the same year or within 10 years. However, because income tax rates rise within each year, receiving them in separate years can result in less tax.[3][4]
- From January 2026, the adjustment when iDeCo is received first was widened from 4 years to 9 years. When the retirement allowance is received first, it stays at 19 years.[4]
Our verdict is “HALF TRUE.” It is exactly as the statute says that the deduction is reduced only for the period in which the deductions overlap. But whether you gain or lose is not decided by whether you receive both in the same year.
There is one question that tells the cases apart: “Is the period in which you paid iDeCo contributions included in the period of service for your retirement allowance?” If it is not included, the deductions do not overlap.
First, we define what “lose out” means
In this article, we split “lose out” into two. One is that the deduction is reduced. The other is that the tax amount increases.
A reduced deduction is an effect of the statute. The overlapping period is counted only once in calculating the deduction.
An increased tax amount is an effect on your household. When the deduction is reduced, the amount subject to tax increases.
These two are not the same. Even if the deduction is reduced, the tax amount stays at 0 as long as the payment is at or below the deduction.
For example, if the retirement allowance is ¥8 million and the deduction is ¥18.5 million, you cannot use the whole deduction. In this case, there is no tax to pay even if the deduction is reduced.
In this article, “lose out” means that the tax amount increases. A reduced deduction is described as its cause.
The statute looks only at the overlapping period
Income Tax Act Article 30, paragraph 6, item 1 provides for the deduction when you received another retirement allowance or similar payment in the previous year or earlier.[1]
その年の前年以前に他の退職手当等の支払を受けている場合で政令で定める場合 [1]
Reference translation (unofficial): where a person received payment of other retirement allowances, etc. in the previous year or earlier, in cases specified by Cabinet Order
The deduction in this case is calculated as follows.
第三項の規定により計算した金額から、当該他の退職手当等につき政令で定めるところにより同項の規定に準じて計算した金額を控除した金額 [1]
Reference translation (unofficial): the amount obtained by subtracting, from the amount calculated under paragraph 3, the amount calculated for those other retirement allowances, etc. in accordance with that paragraph as specified by Cabinet Order
Put simply, it means that the deduction for the earlier retirement allowance or similar payment is subtracted from the deduction for this retirement allowance.
However, only the portion for the overlapping period is subtracted. Article 70, paragraph 1, item 2 of the Order for Enforcement sets that scope.[4]
その重複している部分の期間を法第三十条第三項の勤続年数とみなして同項の規定を適用して計算した金額 [4]
Reference translation (unofficial): the amount calculated by applying Article 30, paragraph 3 of the Act, deeming the overlapping period to be the years of service under that paragraph
In other words, only the overlapping years are treated as years of service when calculating the deduction to be subtracted. If there is no overlap, nothing is subtracted.
The iDeCo period is counted by the period in which you paid contributions
When checking for overlap, how many years does the iDeCo period count as? This is also set by the statute.
Article 69, paragraph 1, item 2 of the Order for Enforcement defines the iDeCo period as the “period relating to individual-type pension participant contributions.”[3]
同法第五十五条第二項第四号(規約の承認)に規定する個人型年金加入者掛金に係る当該個人型年金加入者期間に限るものとし [3]
Reference translation (unofficial): limited to the individual-type pension participation period relating to individual-type pension participant contributions prescribed in Article 55, paragraph 2, item 4 (approval of plan rules) of that Act
Put simply, only the period in which you paid contributions is counted. A period in which the assets were only being invested is not included.
If you moved assets from a corporate DC plan to iDeCo, only the non-overlapping portions are added. The way of counting changes when you move between plans, so check your enrollment records before receiving the money.
If you receive both in the same year, the deduction is combined into one
So what happens if you receive both in the same year? This is the basis for saying “receiving them at the same time makes you lose out.”
When you receive two or more in the same year, the years of service are first calculated using the longest period. Article 69, paragraph 1, item 3 of the Order for Enforcement says so.[3]
その年に二以上の退職手当等又は退職一時金等の支給を受ける場合には、これらの退職手当等又は退職一時金等のそれぞれについて前二号の規定により計算した期間のうち最も長い期間により勤続年数を計算する。ただし、その最も長い期間以外の期間の年数の計算の基礎となつた勤続期間等(勤続期間及び第一号イからハまでの規定により加算すべき期間又は組合員等であつた期間をいう。以下この号において同じ。)の全部又は一部がその最も長い期間の計算の基礎となつた勤続期間等と重複していない場合には、その重複していない勤続期間等について前二号の規定に準じて計算した期間をその最も長い期間に加算して、勤続年数を計算する。 [3]
Reference translation (unofficial): Where a person receives two or more retirement allowances, etc. or retirement lump sums, etc. in that year, the years of service are calculated using the longest of the periods calculated under the preceding two items for each of those retirement allowances, etc. or retirement lump sums, etc. However, where all or part of the period of service, etc. (meaning the period of service and the periods to be added under item 1 (a) to (c), or the period of being a member, etc.; the same applies hereinafter in this item) on which the calculation of the years of a period other than the longest period was based does not overlap with the period of service, etc. on which the calculation of the longest period was based, the years of service are calculated by adding to the longest period the period calculated for the non-overlapping period of service, etc. in accordance with the preceding two items.
Put simply, it means that an overlapping period is counted only once. If there is a period that does not overlap with the longer period, that portion is added.
Suppose the retirement allowance is for 35 years and iDeCo is for 20 years, and the iDeCo period is entirely within the 35 years. There is no non-overlapping period, so the years of service are 35. The deduction is ¥18.5 million, not ¥26.5 million for two separate deductions.
From January 2026, the number of years when iDeCo is received first changed
From here, we turn to the FY2025 (Reiwa 7) tax reform. The number of years looked at differs depending on which you receive first.[4]
| What you receive first | Before the reform (through 2025) | After the reform (from 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Lump sum from iDeCo or a corporate DC plan | Within 4 years | Within 9 years |
| Retirement allowance | Within 19 years | Within 19 years |
You can also compare the statute before and after the reform side by side in the Ministry of Finance’s old-and-new comparison table.[8]
When you receive iDeCo first and then receive a retirement allowance, the period within 9 years is now covered.
その年の前年以前九年内に第七十二条第三項第七号(退職手当等とみなす一時金)に掲げる一時金(令和八年一月一日以後に支払を受けたものに限り、前号に規定する前に支払を受けた退職手当等を除く。)の支払を受け、かつ、その年に退職手当等の支払を受けた場合(ハに掲げる場合に該当する場合を除く。) [4]
Reference translation (unofficial): where a person received payment, within the 9 years up to and including the previous year, of a lump sum listed in Article 72, paragraph 3, item 7 (lump sums deemed to be retirement allowances, etc.) (limited to those received on or after January 1, 2026, and excluding retirement allowances, etc. received before as prescribed in the preceding item), and received payment of retirement allowances, etc. in that year (excluding cases falling under (c))
Conversely, when you receive the retirement allowance first and then receive iDeCo, it stays at 19 years.
その年の前年以前十九年内に退職手当等(前号に規定する前に支払を受けた退職手当等を除く。)の支払を受け、かつ、その年に第七十二条第三項第七号に掲げる一時金の支払を受けた場合 [4]
Reference translation (unofficial): where a person received payment of retirement allowances, etc. (excluding retirement allowances, etc. received before as prescribed in the preceding item) within the 19 years up to and including the previous year, and received payment in that year of a lump sum listed in Article 72, paragraph 3, item 7
Item (b) (ro) covers only lump sums received on or after January 1, 2026. This is because the statute says “limited to those received on or after January 1, 2026 (令和八年一月一日以後に支払を受けたものに限り).”
If you received an iDeCo lump sum before 2026, it does not fall under (b). That lump sum is adjusted under the 4-year rule in item (a) (i).
その年の前年以前四年内に退職手当等(前号に規定する前に支払を受けた退職手当等を除く。)の支払を受け、かつ、その年に退職手当等の支払を受けた場合(ロ及びハに掲げる場合に該当する場合を除く。) [4]
Reference translation (unofficial): where a person received payment of retirement allowances, etc. (excluding retirement allowances, etc. received before as prescribed in the preceding item) within the 4 years up to and including the previous year, and received payment of retirement allowances, etc. in that year (excluding cases falling under (b) and (c))
An iDeCo lump sum is also deemed to be a retirement allowance or similar payment under Income Tax Act Article 31. That is why a lump sum received before 2026 is also adjusted under the 4-year rule in (a).[2]
Then what does (b)(2) provide? It provides that, when (b) applies, earlier retirement allowances or similar payments received before 2026 are limited to those within 4 years.
令和八年一月一日前に支払を受けた退職手当等であつてその年の前年以前四年内に支払を受けたもの [4]
Reference translation (unofficial): retirement allowances, etc. received before January 1, 2026, that were received within the 4 years up to and including the previous year
In other words, an iDeCo lump sum received before 2026 stays under the 4-year rule. The period widens to 9 years only when a lump sum received on or after January 1, 2026 is covered.
The “10-year rule” and “within 9 years” differ only in how they count
The statute says “within the 9 years up to and including the previous year (前年以前九年内).” This means the difference between the years of receipt is 9 years or less; if the difference is 10 years, it is not covered.
The “10-year rule” that people talk about is an informal name for “if you separate them by 10 years, they are not covered.” It does not mean “leaving 9 years in between is enough.” With a 9-year difference, they are still covered.
The old “5-year rule” was counted the same way. The statute said “within the 4 years up to and including the previous year,” and with a 5-year difference they were not covered.
We compare two ways of receiving the same amounts
First, we set the assumptions. The retirement allowance is ¥20 million, for 35 years of service. The iDeCo lump sum is ¥8 million, for 20 years of membership. The iDeCo period is entirely contained within the 35 years of service.
In calculating income tax and resident tax, we do not consider income deductions. Resident tax is only the 10% income-based portion. For income tax, we multiply by 102.1% to include the special income tax for reconstruction, and round down fractions of less than ¥1.[9]
Example 1 is receiving both in 2026.
Example 2 is receiving iDeCo in 2026 and retiring in 2039 after the same 35 years of service. The retirement allowance is received 13 years later. We compare only the overlap of the deductions.[1][3]
| Example 1: received in the same year | Example 2: received 13 years apart | |
|---|---|---|
| Retirement income deduction | ¥18.5 million | iDeCo ¥8 million / retirement allowance ¥18.5 million |
| Taxable retirement income | ¥4.75 million | iDeCo ¥0 / retirement allowance ¥750,000 |
| Income tax (incl. reconstruction tax, rounded down to ¥1) | ¥533,472 | iDeCo ¥0 / retirement allowance ¥38,287 |
| Resident tax (10% income-based portion) | ¥475,000 | iDeCo ¥0 / retirement allowance ¥75,000 |
| Total | ¥1,008,472 | ¥113,287 |
In Example 1, the deduction is calculated only once, based on 35 years of service. Subtracting ¥18.5 million from ¥28 million and taking half of the remainder gives ¥4.75 million.
Income tax is 20% of ¥4.75 million minus ¥427,500, which is ¥522,500. Multiplying this by 102.1% gives ¥533,472.5. Rounding down the fraction of less than ¥1 gives ¥533,472.[9]
In Example 2, the iDeCo payment of ¥8 million is exactly offset by its ¥8 million deduction. For the retirement allowance, subtracting ¥18.5 million from ¥20 million and taking half of the remainder gives ¥750,000.
Income tax is 5% of ¥750,000, which is ¥37,500. Multiplying this by 102.1% gives ¥38,287.5. Rounding down the fraction of less than ¥1 gives ¥38,287.[9]
The difference between the two is ¥895,185. Looking only at this, separating them seems better.
But if you shift them by 3 years, the result is the same. Suppose you receive iDeCo in 2026 and the retirement allowance in 2029.
In this case, the deduction for the retirement allowance is ¥18.5 million minus ¥8 million, which is ¥10.5 million. Taxable retirement income is half of (¥20 million − ¥10.5 million), which is ¥4.75 million. This is the same as Example 1.
Sometimes receiving both in the same year is better
In the examples so far, both payments exceeded their deductions. As long as the iDeCo period is entirely contained in the period of service, under this condition the total deduction does not change whether you receive them in the same year or within 10 years.
When a payment does not reach its deduction, the picture changes.
For example, the retirement allowance is ¥10 million for 35 years of service. iDeCo is ¥12 million, and the period in which contributions were paid is 20 years. The 20 iDeCo years are entirely within the 35 years of service. We compare the case where iDeCo is received first.
If you receive both in the same year, the total payment is ¥22 million. The years of service are 35, so the deduction is ¥18.5 million. Halving the difference of ¥3.5 million gives taxable retirement income of ¥1.75 million.
If you receive them separately, the deduction for iDeCo is ¥8 million. Halving the difference of ¥4 million from ¥12 million gives taxable retirement income of ¥2 million. For the retirement allowance, the ¥10 million payment does not reach the ¥18.5 million deduction, so it is ¥0. The total is ¥2 million.
In this case, receiving both in the same year results in ¥250,000 less. This is because the unused part of the retirement allowance’s deduction is applied to the iDeCo payment.
Note that when the payment of the earlier retirement allowance or similar payment is less than its deduction, one more assumption in the calculation changes. Article 70, paragraph 2 of the Order for Enforcement provides for this treatment.[4]
前の退職手当等の収入金額が前の退職手当等について同号の規定を適用しないで計算した法第三十条第三項の規定による退職所得控除額に満たないときは [4]
Reference translation (unofficial): when the amount of the earlier retirement allowances, etc. is less than the retirement income deduction under Article 30, paragraph 3 of the Act calculated for those earlier retirement allowances, etc. without applying that item
In this case, when calculating the overlapping period, the earlier period is shortened to the number of years that the payment could fully use. If the payment is ¥8 million or less, it is the payment divided by ¥400,000. If it is more than ¥8 million, it is 20 years plus the portion above ¥8 million divided by ¥700,000. Fractions are rounded down.
When the period is shortened, the amount subtracted also becomes smaller. This prevents this year’s deduction from being reduced too much.
A deduction you could not use cannot be carried over to the next year. Income Tax Act Article 30, paragraph 2 calculates income by subtracting the deduction from “the amount of retirement allowances, etc. for that year.” There is no provision to carry it forward to the next year or later.[1]
Who should be careful, and where to check
Lump sums from iDeCo or a corporate DC plan are treated as retirement income. This applies to old-age benefits under the Defined Contribution Pension Act that are received as a lump sum.[5]
A lump sum from a corporate DC plan is subject to the same 9-year and 19-year adjustments as iDeCo. On the other hand, lump sums from a DB plan or from the Mutual Aid for Retirement Allowances of Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (Chūtaikyō) are not defined contribution pension lump sums, so they are subject to the same 4-year adjustment as a retirement allowance. Article 70, paragraph 1, item 2 (a) of the Order provides for that case.[4]
If you are not sure which plan yours is, check with your employer or the pension office before receiving it.
Submit the “Declaration on Receipt of Retirement Income” to the company that pays your retirement allowance. If you do not submit it, 20.42% is withheld.[6][7]
Resident tax is also deducted by the company that pays the retirement allowance at the time of payment. Local Tax Act Article 328-5, paragraph 2 provides that the income-based portion for separate taxation is collected when retirement allowances, etc. are paid.[10] As with income tax, settlement is completed in that year. The effect on National Health Insurance premiums is not covered in this article.
What to do
Before receiving the money, check the following in this order.
| What to check | What to do |
|---|---|
| 1. Do the two periods overlap? | Line up the period in which you paid iDeCo contributions and the period of service for your retirement allowance. For the overlapping period, the deduction cannot be used twice[3] |
| 2. Can you use up the deduction? | Compare the total deduction, taxable retirement income and tax amount in three ways: the same year, within 9 years, and 10 or more years apart. If the iDeCo period is entirely contained in the period of service and both payments exceed their deductions, the total deduction and the total taxable retirement income are the same whether received in the same year or within 9 years. However, because income tax rates rise within each year, receiving them in separate years can result in less tax[4] |
| 3. Which do you receive first? | If you receive iDeCo first, the next retirement allowance is adjusted within 9 years. However, a lump sum received before 2026 is within 4 years. If you receive the retirement allowance first, the next iDeCo is within 19 years[4] |
| 4. Corporate DC, or DB / Chūtaikyō? | Corporate DC is the same as iDeCo, at 9 and 19 years; DB and Chūtaikyō are the same as a retirement allowance, at 4 years. Check with your employer or the pension office[4] |
| 5. Submit the declaration | Submit the "Declaration on Receipt of Retirement Income" to the company that pays your retirement allowance. If you do not submit it, 20.42% is withheld[6][7] |
| 6. Decide the years of receipt | The tax amount changes depending on the order and the years of receipt. Consult a licensed tax accountant before deciding. You can also check how the plans work with the pension office |
Summary
“You lose out if you don’t receive iDeCo at the same time as your retirement allowance” is HALF TRUE.
It is a fact that when the years of receipt are close, the deduction is reduced by the overlapping period. From January 2026, the adjustment when iDeCo is received first was widened from 4 years to 9 years.
But it cannot be said that you lose out unless you receive them at the same time. Even if you receive both in the same year, the deduction is simply combined into one. Within 10 years, the total deduction and the total taxable retirement income are the same, but because income tax rates rise within each year, receiving them in separate years can sometimes result in less tax.
When you cannot use up the deduction, receiving both in the same year can sometimes be better. Whether you gain or lose is not decided only by the combination of years of receipt.
Before deciding the years of receipt, check whether your iDeCo contribution period and your retirement allowance’s period of service overlap. If they overlap, the deduction is combined into one. If they do not overlap, each deduction can be used separately.
If you are unsure, consult a licensed tax accountant.
This article is based on laws and regulations in effect as of November 5, 2026 (Reiwa 8). It is a translation of the Japanese original; if the two differ, the Japanese version prevails. The laws may change with future tax reforms.
Sources
- [1]所得税法 第30条(退職所得) 確認日:2026-11-05
- [2]所得税法 第31条(退職手当等とみなす一時金) 確認日:2026-11-05
- [3]所得税法施行令 第69条(退職所得控除額に係る勤続年数の計算) 確認日:2026-11-05
- [4]所得税法施行令 第70条(退職所得控除額の計算の特例) 確認日:2026-11-05
- [5]所得税法施行令 第72条(退職手当等とみなす一時金) 確認日:2026-11-05
- [6]No.1420 退職所得の受給に関する申告 — 国税庁 確認日:2026-11-05
- [7]No.1210 退職金を受け取ったとき — 国税庁 確認日:2026-11-05
- [8]令和7年度税制改正 所得税法施行令の新旧対照表(第70条関係)— 財務省 確認日:2026-11-05
- [9]No.2732 退職手当等に対する源泉徴収 — 国税庁 確認日:2026-11-05
- [10]地方税法 第328条の5(特別徴収の手続) 確認日:2026-11-05